Refine Your Results
Promotions
Category
Sub-Category
Material
Material Detail
Color
Shape
Brand
Embellishment
Price
Base Metal
Price Range
-
Selected Refinements:

Mythical Creatures

Charms tell a story. Use these mythical creature charms to create jewelry designs with a touch of magic. Shop sterling silver, enameled metals and more.
Read more...
Products (25)
Next Page
Results Per Page 24 | 48 | 96
Sort By
Sort
  • Top Sellers
  • Best Match
  • Newest
  • Price Low to High
  • Price High to Low
  • Product Name A - Z
  • Product Name Z - A
Page 1 of 2
You’re only 15 units from the green discount level.
Limited Quantity
Charm, silver-finished "pewter" (zinc-based alloy) and enamel, green/black/brown/peach, 22x16mm single-sided leprechaun face with glitter hat. Sold per pkg of 2.
6531FX
In Stock

Charm, silver-finished "pewter" (zinc-based alloy) and enamel, green/black/brown/peach, 22x16mm single-sided leprechaun face with glitter hat. Sold per pkg of 2. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
8.34
Current Discount
15-49
$
7.37
Current Discount
50-99
$
6.42
Current Discount
100+
$
5.45
As Low As $2.73 per charm
Limited Quantity
Focal, glass and antiqued pewter (tin-based alloy), clear AB, 34x21mm wizard. Sold individually.
7150FN
In Stock - Only 38 Available

Focal, glass and antiqued pewter (tin-based alloy), clear AB, 34x21mm wizard. Sold individually. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
14.73
Current Discount
15-49
$
13.23
Current Discount
50-99
$
11.73
Current Discount
100+
$
10.23
As Low As $10.23 per charm
Regular Stock
Charm, antique silver-plated "pewter" (zinc-based alloy), 29x26mm single-sided dragon. Sold per pkg of 10.
9188FY
In Stock

Charm, antique silver-plated "pewter" (zinc-based alloy), 29x26mm single-sided dragon. Sold per pkg of 10. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
6.49
Current Discount
15-49
$
5.74
Current Discount
50-99
$
5.00
Current Discount
100+
$
4.24
As Low As $0.43 per charm
Regular Stock
Charm, enamel and silver-plated "pewter" (zinc-based alloy), black / white / red, 32x13mm single-sided vampire. Sold individually.
A2570FN
In Stock

Charm, enamel and silver-plated "pewter" (zinc-based alloy), black / white / red, 32x13mm single-sided vampire. Sold individually. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
7.85
Current Discount
15-49
$
6.93
Current Discount
50-99
$
6.04
Current Discount
100+
$
5.12
As Low As $5.12 per charm
Get your FREE catalog here.
Regular Stock
Charm, antiqued sterling silver, 14x13mm two-sided Pegasus. Sold individually.
9401FN
In Stock

Charm, antiqued sterling silver, 14x13mm two-sided Pegasus. Sold individually. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
37.36
Current Discount
15-49
$
33.53
Current Discount
50-99
$
29.74
Current Discount
100+
$
25.96
As Low As $25.96 per charm
Regular Stock
Charm, antiqued sterling silver, 11x10mm 3D pumpkin carriage. Sold individually.
2796FD
In Stock

Charm, antiqued sterling silver, 11x10mm 3D pumpkin carriage. Sold individually. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
63.76
Current Discount
15-49
$
58.23
Current Discount
50-99
$
52.68
Current Discount
100+
$
47.19
As Low As $47.19 per charm
Limited Quantity
Charm, antique silver-plated pewter (tin-based alloy), 9x5.5mm-25x18mm assorted Halloween theme. Sold per 8-piece set.
A9211FN
In Stock - Only 52 Available

Charm, antique silver-plated pewter (tin-based alloy), 9x5.5mm-25x18mm assorted Halloween theme. Sold per 8-piece set. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
21.04
Current Discount
15-49
$
19.23
Current Discount
50-99
$
17.41
Current Discount
100+
$
15.59
As Low As $1.95 per charm
Limited Quantity
Charm, acrylic and antique copper-finished "pewter" (zinc-based alloy), black / white / orange, 17mm single-sided flat round with spider / bats / ghost with pumpkin design. Sold per 3-piece set.
8457FX
In Stock

Charm, acrylic and antique copper-finished "pewter" (zinc-based alloy), black / white / orange, 17mm single-sided flat round with spider / bats / ghost with pumpkin design. Sold per 3-piece set. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
5.22
Current Discount
15-49
$
4.61
Current Discount
50-99
$
4.01
Current Discount
100+
$
3.40
As Low As $1.14 per charm
Regular Stock
Charm Amoracast® 1pkg1 sterling silver, 16x8.5mm 2-sided open mermaid
B7482FN
In Stock

Charm Amoracast® 1pkg1 sterling silver, 16x8.5mm 2-sided open mermaid Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
10.23
Current Discount
15-49
$
9.20
Current Discount
50-99
$
8.16
Current Discount
100+
$
7.11
As Low As $7.11 per charm
Regular Stock
Charm, silver-plated "pewter" (zinc-based alloy) and enamel, white and green, 25x23mm single-sided mummy. Sold individually.
7191FX
In Stock

Charm, silver-plated "pewter" (zinc-based alloy) and enamel, white and green, 25x23mm single-sided mummy. Sold individually. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
7.99
Current Discount
15-49
$
7.18
Current Discount
50-99
$
6.37
Current Discount
100+
$
5.55
As Low As $5.55 per charm
Regular Stock
Drop, antiqued sterling silver, 25x18.5mm Celtic dragon. Sold individually.
5741FN
In Stock

Drop, antiqued sterling silver, 25x18.5mm Celtic dragon. Sold individually. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
86.01
Current Discount
15-49
$
78.56
Current Discount
50-99
$
71.11
Current Discount
100+
$
63.69
As Low As $63.69 per casting
Regular Stock
Charm, enamel and silver-plated "pewter" (zinc-based alloy), white and orange, 27x21mm single-sided ghost with "Trick or Treat" banner. Sold individually.
A2578FN
In Stock

Charm, enamel and silver-plated "pewter" (zinc-based alloy), white and orange, 27x21mm single-sided ghost with "Trick or Treat" banner. Sold individually. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
7.85
Current Discount
15-49
$
6.93
Current Discount
50-99
$
6.04
Current Discount
100+
$
5.12
As Low As $5.12 per charm
Regular Stock
Charm, antiqued sterling silver, 17x14mm goddess moon face. Sold individually.
2502FN
In Stock

Charm, antiqued sterling silver, 17x14mm goddess moon face. Sold individually. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
49.42
Current Discount
15-49
$
44.35
Current Discount
50-99
$
39.37
Current Discount
100+
$
34.32
As Low As $34.32 per casting
Regular Stock
Charm, silver-plated "pewter" (zinc-based alloy) and enamel, multicolored, 24x20mm single-sided ghost and pumpkin. Sold individually.
7180FX
In Stock

Charm, silver-plated "pewter" (zinc-based alloy) and enamel, multicolored, 24x20mm single-sided ghost and pumpkin. Sold individually. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
7.06
Current Discount
15-49
$
6.24
Current Discount
50-99
$
5.43
Current Discount
100+
$
4.61
As Low As $4.61 per charm
Limited Quantity
Charm, antiqued silver-finished "pewter" (zinc-based alloy), 19x12mm double-sided cupid. Sold per pkg of 20.
8849FY
In Stock

Charm, antiqued silver-finished "pewter" (zinc-based alloy), 19x12mm double-sided cupid. Sold per pkg of 20. Product Title

Buy More, Save More
Details

The more you buy, the more you save: Spend $30 in The Buy More, Save More Sale and get 10% off those items. Or spend $60 for 20% off, $100 for 30% or $200 for a whopping 40% off! See the savings automatically apply to the "Extended" prices in your cart on qualifying products. Order amount excludes gift certificates.

Sale ends February 16, 2026 at 11:59 p.m. PT or while supplies last.
Current Discount
1-14
$
3.64
Current Discount
15-49
$
3.18
Current Discount
50-99
$
2.76
Current Discount
100+
$
2.30
As Low As $0.12 per charm
Limited Quantity
Charm, gold-finished "pewter" (zinc-based alloy) and enamel, green / black / brown / peach, 22x16mm single-sided leprechaun face with glitter hat. Sold per pkg of 2.
6530FX
In Stock

Charm, gold-finished "pewter" (zinc-based alloy) and enamel, green / black / brown / peach, 22x16mm single-sided leprechaun face with glitter hat. Sold per pkg of 2. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
8.34
Current Discount
15-49
$
7.37
Current Discount
50-99
$
6.42
Current Discount
100+
$
5.45
As Low As $2.73 per charm
Regular Stock
Charm, antiqued sterling silver, 22x12mm unicorn. Sold individually.
2769FY
In Stock

Charm, antiqued sterling silver, 22x12mm unicorn. Sold individually. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
37.27
Current Discount
15-49
$
33.44
Current Discount
50-99
$
29.65
Current Discount
100+
$
25.88
As Low As $25.88 per charm
Limited Quantity
Charm, acrylic and antique copper-finished "pewter" (zinc-based alloy), black / white / orange, 17mm flat round with skeleton / 18x15mm flat oval with ghost head / 17x16mm pumpkin with skull and crossbones. Sold per 3-piece set.
8456FX
In Stock - Only 10 Available

Charm, acrylic and antique copper-finished "pewter" (zinc-based alloy), black / white / orange, 17mm flat round with skeleton / 18x15mm flat oval with ghost head / 17x16mm pumpkin with skull and crossbones. Sold per 3-piece set. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
5.22
Current Discount
15-49
$
4.61
Current Discount
50-99
$
4.01
Current Discount
100+
$
3.40
As Low As $1.14 per charm
Regular Stock
Charm, silver-plated "pewter" (zinc-based alloy) and enamel, multicolored, 25x21mm single-sided witch's head. Sold individually.
7188FX
In Stock

Charm, silver-plated "pewter" (zinc-based alloy) and enamel, multicolored, 25x21mm single-sided witch's head. Sold individually. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
7.99
Current Discount
15-49
$
7.18
Current Discount
50-99
$
6.37
Current Discount
100+
$
5.55
As Low As $5.55 per charm
Regular Stock
Charm, silver-plated "pewter" (zinc-based alloy) and enamel, orange / black / yellow, 25x19mm single-sided witch's hat, broom and pumpkin. Sold individually.
7186FX
In Stock

Charm, silver-plated "pewter" (zinc-based alloy) and enamel, orange / black / yellow, 25x19mm single-sided witch's hat, broom and pumpkin. Sold individually. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
7.06
Current Discount
15-49
$
6.24
Current Discount
50-99
$
5.43
Current Discount
100+
$
4.61
As Low As $4.61 per charm
Limited Quantity
Charm, acrylic and antique copper-finished "pewter" (zinc-based alloy), black / white / orange, 17mm flat round with ghost / 18x15mm flat oval with spider / 17x14mm tombstone with cat. Sold per 3-piece set.
8459FX
In Stock - Only 75 Available

Charm, acrylic and antique copper-finished "pewter" (zinc-based alloy), black / white / orange, 17mm flat round with ghost / 18x15mm flat oval with spider / 17x14mm tombstone with cat. Sold per 3-piece set. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
5.22
Current Discount
15-49
$
4.61
Current Discount
50-99
$
4.01
Current Discount
100+
$
3.40
As Low As $1.14 per charm
Regular Stock
Charm, sterling silver, 12x9mm unicorn. Sold per pkg of 2.
5893JW
In Stock

Charm, sterling silver, 12x9mm unicorn. Sold per pkg of 2. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
25.34
Current Discount
15-49
$
22.40
Current Discount
50-99
$
19.49
Current Discount
100+
$
16.55
As Low As $8.28 per charm
Limited Quantity
Charm, gold-finished "pewter" (zinc-based alloy) and enamel, green / white / peach, 15x10mm single-sided lucky elf face with glitter hat. Sold per pkg of 2.
6533FX
In Stock

Charm, gold-finished "pewter" (zinc-based alloy) and enamel, green / white / peach, 15x10mm single-sided lucky elf face with glitter hat. Sold per pkg of 2. Product Title

SAVE
54%
Regular Price:
$
11.01
Sale Price:
$
5.01
Only $2.51 per charm
Limited Quantity
Sterling silver and enamel cupid charm, approximately 16x24mm. Sold individually.
4225FD
In Stock - Only 39 Available

Sterling silver and enamel cupid charm, approximately 16x24mm. Sold individually. Product Title

Current Discount
1-14
$
88.63
Current Discount
15-49
$
80.95
Current Discount
50-99
$
73.29
Current Discount
100+
$
65.65
As Low As $65.65 per charm
Results Per Page 24 | 48 | 96
Sort By
Sort
  • Top Sellers
  • Best Match
  • Newest
  • Price Low to High
  • Price High to Low
  • Product Name A - Z
  • Product Name Z - A

25 Item(s) Found Items Found.

Page 1 of 2
Next Page